I Played Along to See What Happened

I accepted a friend request from someone I haven’t thought about in 50 years. I knew it was almost certainly a scammer the moment I saw the profile. Here’s what I learned when I deliberately played along for a day—and how to recognize these fakes before they fool you.

The Red Flag That Made Me Suspicious: AI-Generated Profile Pictures

The friend request came from a name I recognized—someone who babysat me decades ago. But the profile picture was the first alarm bell. It was clearly an AI-generated version of a much younger version of this person. The features were slightly off, the styling had that uncanny quality that AI images have, and it didn’t match any real photo I could find of this person.

That alone should have been enough. But there was more.

The tandem account? Also had an AI-generated profile picture—a different person, same telltale signs.

When two accounts show up simultaneously with AI-generated photos, especially ones connected to you through mutual friends, that’s not coincidence. That’s a coordinated scam operation.

How to Spot AI-Generated Profile Pictures

If you’re not sure, here’s what to look for:

Common AI photo tells:

  • Slightly asymmetrical facial features (one eye or ear subtly different from the other)
  • Unnaturally smooth, plastic-looking skin (especially for older faces)
  • Hair that looks airbrushed or lacks realistic texture
  • Teeth that are too perfect, too uniform, or oddly shaped
  • Hands that are deformed, blurry, or have odd proportions (AI still struggles with hands)
  • Eyes that don’t quite focus in the same direction
  • Backgrounds that are blurry or oddly rendered
  • Inconsistent lighting across different parts of the face
  • Jewelry, buttons, or small details that don’t quite look right

What to do if you spot an AI photo:

  • Do not accept the friend request
  • Report the account immediately (we’ll cover how below)
  • If you know the real person being impersonated, warn them

The Scam Pattern I Observed

I accepted the request deliberately to see how far it would go. Here’s what happened:

Day 1 (Within an hour of accepting):
A messenger message appeared with that characteristic opener—something that sounded personal enough to seem real, but generic enough to work on anyone.

The faker claimed to be the person in the profile. They had done their homework: they knew the relationship between me and the real person. They sent a link to “their” profile where a post showed a photo of “her” with “me” (a child). That photo was posted by the tandem account, and obviously sourced from the real person’s actual social media.

My response? I said, “I remember her well. Who are you?”

That’s the moment the scammer felt like they had a fish on the hook. A real victim would be confused, curious, and emotionally engaged. I was deliberately testing where they’d take it.

Their response: They insisted they were the person they were impersonating.

Day 2:
The fake account called me through Messenger. I didn’t answer. That same day, I dug into both accounts:

  • The fake account had a small friend list
  • Except for the tandem account, none of the friends were names that made sense
  • The activity and interaction patterns were machine-like

I reported both accounts and blocked them.

What they were fishing for: Typically, these scams escalate to money requests (usually gift cards or wire transfers), requests for personal information, or attempts to compromise your security further. But sometimes they’re just trying to get through the gate. Once they’re your “friend,” they can copy or download your Facebook posts to create another fake account—this time using your name at the top of the page. They can see your friends list, so the fake profile of YOU starts sending friend requests to your actual friends. Now your friends think the scammer IS you.

What This Is NOT

“My Facebook was hacked.”

When someone says “my Facebook was hacked,” here’s what usually actually happened:

  • Most common: They forgot their own password and got locked out of their account (it’s embarrassing to admit, so they blame a hack)
  • Less common but real: Someone did get unauthorized access and changed the password (this IS actual hacking)

The problem: People who experience the second scenario sometimes panic and just create a new account instead of recovering the hacked one. This does NOT solve the problem. The hacked account is still out there, still being used to scam other people.

What to do instead: If your account is actually compromised, use Facebook’s recovery tools to regain control and lock out the person who took it. If you can’t recover it, report it to Facebook as a compromised account (not just an impersonation). Don’t just abandon it and create a new one—that leaves a fake account impersonating you for months.


Step-by-Step: What to Do Right Now

Step 1: Stop Engaging

  • Do not reply to messages from the suspicious account
  • Do not answer calls from Messenger
  • Do not click links they send
  • Stop here. You’re already ahead of most victims.

Step 2: Gather Intel (Optional, But Helpful)

Before you report, take a screenshot of:

  • Their profile page
  • Any suspicious messages or calls
  • The fake profile name vs. the real person’s name
  • Friends list (look for accounts that seem out of place or don’t match real friend groups)
  • The profile picture (if it looks AI-generated, note that specifically)

You don’t need to be a detective here—Facebook’s moderation team will do the heavy lifting. But screenshots help.

Step 3: Report the Fake Account to Facebook

On Desktop:

  1. Go to the fake account’s profile
  2. Click the three dots (•••) in the top right
  3. Select “Report”
  4. Choose “It’s pretending to be someone”
  5. Select who the account is impersonating (the real person)
  6. Facebook will ask if you know the real person—say yes
  7. Complete the report

On Mobile (Facebook App):

  1. Visit the fake profile
  2. Tap the three dots (•••) at the top
  3. Select “Report”
  4. Choose “It’s pretending to be someone”
  5. Follow the prompts

Step 4: Block the Fake Account

Do this immediately after reporting:

  1. Go back to their profile
  2. Tap “Block” (usually a button near their name)
  3. Confirm you want to block them
  4. They cannot:
    • Message you
    • See your profile
    • Add you as a friend
    • See your posts or photos

Step 4B: About Those Links, Images, and Messenger Content

This is critical: Do not click links, images, or other content sent by suspicious accounts in Messenger.

Here’s why: When you click a link or download content from Messenger, you’re potentially:

  • Landing on a phishing site that looks like Facebook but steals your login
  • Downloading malware
  • Triggering tracking code that maps your device and browser habits
  • Exposing personal data stored on your device

“But what if I’m just curious?”

If you absolutely must click (and we all have that impulse), here’s what matters: Use an iPhone, not a Windows computer or Android phone.

Why the difference?

iPhone (iOS):

  • Apps run in isolated “sandboxes”—each app is walled off from the rest of your device
  • Even if the link downloads malware, it has very limited access to your photos, contacts, passwords, or other apps
  • The system is tightly controlled; malware can’t easily spread
  • If something goes wrong, you can delete the app and the problem is contained

Android Phone:

  • More granular permissions, but less strict isolation
  • Apps request permissions (camera, contacts, files, location), and once granted, they can access broad categories of your data
  • Malware can request legitimate-sounding permissions and get system-level access
  • Harder to contain damage once it spreads

Windows Computer:

  • Your browser and operating system are deeply integrated
  • Malware can gain system-level access to ALL your files, passwords, and programs
  • A compromised browser can see everything: banking logins, email, documents, search history
  • Ransomware can encrypt your entire hard drive
  • Recovery is difficult and often expensive

The reality: If a scammer gets Windows malware on your computer, they might steal your identity, financial information, or hold your files hostage. On Android, it’s serious but slightly more contained. On iPhone, the damage is typically limited to that one app.

Bottom line: Don’t click suspicious links at all. But if curiosity wins (we’re human), an iPhone is exponentially safer than either a Windows PC or Android phone.

Step 5: Report the Tandem Account (If You Identify It)

If you spotted a second account working with the fake one:

  1. Follow the same reporting steps
  2. If you’re on their friends list and feel unsure, you can:
    • Remove them from your friends (unfriend)
    • Block them if the behavior is suspicious

Red flag for a tandem account:

  • Brand new account with few friends
  • Friends list includes other suspicious accounts
  • Inconsistent profile information
  • AI-generated profile picture
  • Sent you the friend request right before the fake account contacted you

Step 6: Protect Your Photos from Being Copied

This is the step most people skip—and it’s critical.

The easiest way: Use Facebook’s Privacy Checkup

  1. Go to Settings & Privacy → Privacy Checkup
  2. Click on “Who can see what you share”
  3. Set “Who can see your posts?” to “Friends”
  4. Set “Who can see your stories?” to “Friends”
  5. Review and adjust any other settings that matter to you

This controls who can see and download your photos and posts going forward. Anyone who’s not a friend won’t be able to copy them.

Alternative route (if Privacy Checkup isn’t available):

  1. Go to Settings & Privacy → Settings
  2. Click “Default Audience Settings”
  3. Click “Custom”
  4. Set “Who can see your future posts?” to “Friends”
  5. Set “Who can see your stories?” to “Friends”
  6. Click “Done”

Don’t accept friend requests from:

  • Accounts with AI-generated profile pictures
  • Accounts with very few friends
  • Profiles with only a few photos or activity
  • People you don’t actually know, even if the name looks familiar
  • Anyone who immediately pivots to a call or money request

Step 7: Alert the Real Person (Optional)

If you know the actual person being impersonated, you might message them directly (through a verified account—phone, email, or mutual friends) to let them know their identity is being used. They should:

  1. Report the fake account
  2. Consider a privacy audit (see below)

Protect Your Account: A Quick Privacy Audit

While you’re in Settings, consider these changes:

SettingRecommendationWhy
Who can see your posts?Friends OnlyLimits what scammers can copy
Who can contact you?Friends OnlyReduces unsolicited messages
Who can look you up by phone/email?Friends OnlyHarder for scammers to find you
Old posts visibilityReview and restrictDecide who sees your history

What NOT to Do

❌ Don’t create a new account if you’re the victim. Report and block instead.

❌ Don’t assume it’s “just” a bot. Organized scam networks are running these accounts.

❌ Don’t click “Forgot Password” on the fake account. You’ll just confirm the account exists.


The Bottom Line

These scams work because they exploit familiarity and emotion. When you see a name from your past, you want to believe it. That’s the hook.

The good news? The warning signs are becoming more obvious. AI-generated profile pictures are getting better, but they’re still not perfect. Coordinated fake accounts follow patterns. And Facebook’s reporting system actually works—they notified me within 24 hours that one of the accounts I reported had already violated their terms of service.

If you see something suspicious, report it. Block it. Move on. You’re already protecting your community by not letting the scammer think they have a successful target.


Have you encountered a Facebook scam? What red flags did you spot? Share this post on your Facebook Page and tell your friends to be aware and alert. As a community, knowledge takes the power away from the scammers, fakers, and downright bad people.


This post is based on a real encounter where I deliberately played along to observe the scam in action. I reported both accounts within 24 hours.

Note: Scams and platform security evolve constantly. If you’re curious, you can also read a previous post on this topic — written a while back, but still worth a look for context.

Get a Geek!